Is New Moon Depressing?

I didnt know what to call this topic...but does any one find that reading New Moon depresses them? I sure do! It makes me so sad reading about Edward leaving! And the cullens are hardly in it at all...

^^haha i did the exact same thing, in fact i think i did a little dance when alice came back!

KK, it is verry depressing. And you know I think that...

It's depressing at first but you have to look deeper into it and realize that it's actually really sweet. Do you think you could ever lose someone or something that you live for? I probably couldn't but Edward was doing that to protect Bella even though he could hardly bare it. He said that some days he would just curl up into a ball and lay there. I mean, c'mon, that's soo sweet in a sad way though.

yeah that is sweet...

but think if you actually thought that person didnt love you anymore...and would just leave

that must have been hard for eddie to leave her there in the woods...*sniff* see....more depression

It is so depressing...I cry in 3 places every time I read it. When Edward leaves (duh) when Jake is being all stupid and telling her they can't hang out anymore and when Edward comes back (but those are happy tears). So most of it is sad, but the happiness is worth it. I didn't think happy tears were actually possible until I read it. *sighs* Twilight makes everything possible. And keep in mind that New Moon is a huge changing experience for Bella and Edward. It had to happen, even if it sucks.

I don't care. Anything cannot cheer me up when I read New Moon. Its so sad! I always cry when Edward leaves Bella. TO JAKE. How could he be soo stupid!

It's so sad... When I was reading New Moon again I would usually skip to the part where they go and find Edward. The rest of the book, to me, is sort of boring without the Cullen's'.

Haha, that's what I thought when I reread it the first couple of times. But then, I started to really appreciate New Moon a lot more and see what it symbolized and everything.

i love how the plot is so similar to Romeo and Juliet but then so different...because it has a happier ending and stuff

I didn't find that New Moon was depressing, just extremely long.

At this point in the story, even though there is only one book beforehand, the idea of Bella and Edward being together is just so firmly imprinted (heh) on your mind, that the story seems at a loss when he isn't there.

However, every time I read New Moon over, I find it easier and easier to read because each time I see what an important part of the story it is. The fact that they both made huge mistakes (Bella and Edward) and yet they still found each other, still went back to each other, only strengthened their relationship.

I honestly don't think that Bella and Edward would be, could be, Bella and Edward, without that period of pain and loss in New Moon.

First I found New Moon really sad and annoying. I read it in one day, because I thought it sucked. lol
But now I think it's something that needed to happen, just like Jag said.